One aspect of the USA’s constitution that makes the country somewhat unique in a global context is the state and federal system. While the US has a set of laws made at a national or federal level, each state also has its own set of laws which might be quite different from state to state. These laws often reflect the culture or values of that state to some extent.

Laws exist for different purposes, but one major class or type of law is consumer protection. Consumer protection laws are made to protect consumers against poor practice or standards by manufacturers or companies. One type of consumer protection laws that are standard in the USA are Lemon Laws.

What is the Purpose of Lemon Laws?

A Lemon Law exists to protect consumers from purchasing vehicles that have been poorly manufactured. If you buy a new car and find that it’s constantly breaking down or has the same recurring problem which is impossible to fix, you might have bought a lemon. Fortunately, Lemon Laws across the USA are in place for this very reason. Under certain circumstances, Lemon Laws state that you are eligible for compensation if your vehicle is faulty or defective.

For example, if you bought a new car a few months ago and it’s already broken down, you might be wondering if you’ve bought a lemon. This might be the case, and if it is, then the Lemon Laws exist to stipulate the kind of compensation you are eligible for- generally, a replacement vehicle, or a refund. However, there are certain criteria you need to meet in order for your car to be considered a lemon.

What Qualifies Under the Lemon Law?

Not all defective vehicles qualify under the Lemon Law. There are a number of criteria that the vehicle needs to meet to be considered a lemon. Just because your new or used car has broken down a couple of times, doesn’t necessarily mean it is going to be considered a lemon, for example. One of the most important parts of the Lemon Law is that the manufacturer has attempted to repair your car several times. The number of repair attempts is not stipulated under the Lemon Law, but you can generally expect that the manufacturer has made at least three or four repair attempts before your vehicle can be considered a lemon.

Also, the repair attempts need to have been made within the first or second years of you owning the car, regardless of whether or not it’s a new vehicle or used car. In addition, you have to have been unable to use your car for at least 30 days since purchasing it due to repair works. The 30 days do not have to be a single period, nor do they have to be consecutive.

Another requirement is that your vehicle is under warranty. However, it doesn’t have to be under warranty when you file the claim, or throughout the entire period of repairs. If your vehicle was under warranty when the first repair attempt was made by the manufacturer, then this should be sufficient for it to be covered under the Lemon Law.

Practical Advice

There are some things you should keep in mind to give your Lemon Law claim the best chance of success. Generally, if your new vehicle needs to be repaired several times not long after you purchase it, then it can be considered a lemon. However, it’s ultimately up to you to be able to prove that your new or used car is a lemon. One thing you must do is only get your vehicle repaired by the manufacturer. You can do this by taking it back to the dealership where you bought it. If you get your new or used car repaired by a third party, then the manufacturer cannot be legally held accountable for its work.

This is why you must ensure that you keep records of all the repair works done on your new or used car. A Lemons Law stipulates that your new or used car has had a reasonable amount of repair work attempted on it, and you need to prove that this is the case when trying to claim compensation. The L e m o n Law also states that you must have been unable to use your vehicle due to repair work, so you need to be able to document this somehow, too.

You may also want to consider hiring an attorney for your case to help you with putting it together and filing. An attorney who specializes in consumers law can help you put together the best case, to give you the best possible chance of success. A consumer may also need help interpreting the more complex parts of the Lemon Law, depending on the state that they are in. Attorney fees might be steep, but they are generally worth it to give your case the best chance of success.

How Does the State Lemon Law Protect Consumers?

Lemon Laws at the state level can protect consumers in a number of ways. First and foremost, they require vehicle manufacturers or dealers to compensate consumers that have purchased a lemon. Generally, a manufacturer or dealer has to compensate consumers with a refund or a replacement vehicle.

Also, Lemon Laws protect consumers with certain features, that operate in the favor of the consumer. One example of this would be a Lemon Law presumption. In some states in the USA, there is a presumption in place under the Lemon Law. This means that, under certain circumstances, a court is going to automatically consider a car to be a lemon, and this means the owner is automatically eligible for compensation.

One example of this would be the Lemon Law presumption in California. Under California state law, a vehicle is presumed to be a lemon if it is less than 18 months old or has been driven less than 18,000 miles, and has had to be repaired a certain number of times. Generally, the vehicle needs to have been taken for repairs at least four times. However, if the problems with the vehicle are considered to be potentially life threatening, or they have the potential to cause serious injury, then the vehicle only needs to have been taken for repairs twice.

A vehicle may also be considered a lemon under the Lemon Law presumption if repairs on the vehicle have meant that the owner has not been able to use it for at least 30 days. This does not have to be a consecutive period of 30 days, however.

Also, under Californian State Law, the vehicle generally needs to have been purchased for personal or business purposes. Unless it was purchased by a member of the Armed Forces stationed in California, the vehicle needs to have been purchased or leased in California, as well.

Is There a Used Car Lemon Law in Certain States?

Some states in the US have a special Lemon Law for used cars. While all states have a new car Lemon Law, only six states have a used car Lemon Law. They are Minnesota, Massachusetts, Hawaii, New Jersey, New York, and Rhode Island. Each of these state laws have different stipulations for the amount of wear a vehicle can have and still be considered a lemon.

In addition, there are a further seven states where the state Lemon Laws have a minimum standard for selling used vehicles. While this doesn’t explicitly protect car buyers from purchasing a lemon, the standards have to be met if a dealership is going to sell a used car. As such, these restrictions work to protect car buyers, though they do not work explicitly as Lemon Laws. These states are New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, Connecticut, Maine, and Pennsylvania.

Which State Has the Best Lemon Laws?

Lemon Laws vary quite considerably from state to state, and it’s difficult to say which state has the best law. Lemon Laws protect car buyers in different ways, so what one considers to be the best may depend considerably on what one considers to be good consumer protection in the first place. However, there are arguably a set of states whose lemon laws are the most comprehensive, and do the best job of protecting consumers from bad practice or manufacturing.

In fact, the Center for Auto Safety has released a ranking of the States which it considers to have the best or most comprehensive lemon laws. According to the Center for Auto Safety, these Lemon Laws are the best at protecting consumers from being taken advantage of by manufacturers. When it developed the ranking, the CAS looked at lots of different factors from the perspective of consumer rights and protection. Among other things, the CAS considered how long a consumer may have owned a new vehicle before it can be considered a lemon, as well as the number of repair attempts that are required to have been made on a new vehicle.

The CAS also considered the amount of time consumers may lose while their new vehicle is being repaired by the manufacturer. In addition, the CAS considered whether or not the manufacturer can be penalized for wilfully violating state laws. Finally, the CAS also considered whether or not attorney fees can be covered under those state laws, if the vehicle is found to be a lemon, even if it is a used car. Lemon laws differ considerably in these areas.

New Jersey

According to the CAS, New Jersey has some of the most protective state lemon laws in the USA. In New Jersey, the lemon laws are very protective of consumers in general, and also cover used car lemon purchases. This makes the state an especially safe place to purchase a new vehicle, as the laws are so protective of consumers and generally work in the favor of the consumer. It’s also quite easy to see that filing a claim under lemon laws in New Jersey is made relatively easy by the state compared to some other states.

While there are some types of used vehicles that are not covered by the lemon laws in New Jersey, these are far and few between. According to the CAS, consumers are clearly favored by the legal structure in New Jersey.

New York

Another state that the CAS considered to have very protective lemon laws is New York. Compared to some other states, the law in New York is much less restrictive, covering a wider variety of vehicles and with fewer stipulations. This means that consumers in the state of New York can be confident in purchasing a new vehicle that they are highly likely to be protected by the state’s Lemon Laws.

District of Columbia

The CAS also considers the District of Columbia to have great Lemon Laws. According to the CAS, the state is generally supportive of consumers instead of manufacturers, working in their favor to protect them from poor or negligent manufacturing standards or practices.

I Think My Car is a Lemon – What Do I Do?

If you think you’ve bought a lemon, try not to panic. While this can be a very frustrating experience, you have some legal recourse if the manufacturer has refused to refund you or replace the vehicle. Depending on where you are in the USA, the laws are going to vary somewhat, but you are going to be covered at the federal level if you meet the critera laid out in the federal laws.

The first thing you should do if your vehicle is dysfunctional and the manufacturer is refusing to replace it or refund you is contact an attorney specializing in cases like these. An experienced attorney can go through your case with you, and advise you as to whether or not you’re likely to be eligible for compensation. If you are, your attorney can help you to prepare a case that is compelling and has all the necessary evidence, and then file the case on your behalf.

Depending on where you are in the USA, you may be protected by presumptions, which make it much easier to file claims and for the court to decide in your favor. However, this isn’t a requirement. Your attorney is going to know the ins and outs of this, and help you to put together the strongest possible case, regardless of your circumstances. Attorney fees can be steep, but they are worth it to make sure your case succeeds in court. Also, your attorney fees may be waived if the court decides in your favor- this depends on where you are in the USA, however.

If the case is decided in your favor, then your attorney can also help you to contact the manufacturer to get the compensation you are entitled to. By working with an attorney, you can make the whole process much easier for yourself, as well as giving yourself the best chance at success. Save yourself the frustration of going through the courts and legal system, and let a competent attorney do it on your behalf. This is going to make life much easier for you in the long run, as well as making your case much more likely to succeed.

All rights reserved.